Saturday, August 18, 2012

US blooger accuses Senator Tito Sotto as a "Lying thief"

An American woman has called Sen. Vicente Sotto III a “lying thief” and accused the Senate majority leader of plagiarizing her blog during an acrimonious debate on the reproductive health (RH) bill that pitted supporters of the bill against the Catholic Church and other sectors that consider artificial contraception as abortion.

Sotto initially denied using part of Sarah Pope’s blog when he argued against the bill to distribute contraceptives in government-run health clinics, but after the salty label came out in her blog on Thursday, the senator’s chief of staff, Hector Villacorta, acknowledged that they had used Pope’s blog without any attribution.

The senator continued to deny the plagiarism allegation, saying that both he and Pope had cited the same source, Russian-born physician Dr. Natasha Campbell-McBride who claims that contraceptives cause an imbalance between good and bad bacteria in the intestines that breaks down the defense against infection.

He also took exception to the blogger’s charge that he is “a lying thief.”

‘Umbrella attribution’

“They must be mistaken. What I delivered in the plenary is different from the one that was written,” Sotto said in a telephone interview.

“I have an umbrella attribution [in my speech],” he added, referring to his disclaimer that what he said on the floor was based on research and not his own.

Sotto also referred to Article 6 Section 11 of the Philippine Constitution which says in part: “No member [of Congress] shall be questioned nor be held liable in any other place for any speech or debate in the Congress or in any committee thereof.”

“Why would I quote from a blogger? She is just a blogger,” Sotto said.

Villacorta said he saw nothing wrong with using Pope’s blog without any attribution because it is “public domain” and “blogs are not covered by copyright.”   He added, “It is a new media and there is no jurisprudence yet.”

‘Dilatory filibustering’

In the House of Representatives, supporters of the RH bill are bracing themselves for the possibility that the measure would not survive what the RH bill’s principal author,  Albay Rep. Edcel Lagman, has described as “the malevolent and dilatory filibustering” of lawmakers opposed to House Bill No.  4244.

Iloilo Rep. Janette Garin, a coauthor of the bill, said there was an “understanding” among proponents that the measure would no longer be filed in the next Congress should it fail in the current one.

“If it loses, (the bill) will not be tackled in the next Congresses anymore,” Garin said in a phone interview, recalling discussions among her colleagues prior to the Aug. 6 vote that terminated plenary debate on HB 4244. “If (the bill) is tackled at all, perhaps it would only come after a few years, perhaps after 10 years,” she said, adding that she and other proponents remained “committed” to passing the RH bill into law.

Not yet mature

Garin said that if the RH bill were defeated in the 15th Congress, it would be “a proof that our country is not yet mature for that law.”

But whatever the House vote is on HB 4244, the Iloilo representative said legislative work on the measure should be completed.

“Our point is, if you don’t want to pass it, then vote against it,” Garin said. “To be fair to everybody, including the real Filipino people who really want this bill, let’s decide on this. If we have the numbers, then okay.  To be honest, we’re also not sure (if we have the numbers),” she said.

“If we don’t have the numbers, at least, the people would know that (the bill can’t be passed) so we can probably proceed with existing programs, depending on the political will of local chief executives,”  Garin said.

In June this year, Health Secretary Enrique Ona announced that his department would distribute around P500 million in condoms and other contraceptives to help address the problem of rising maternal mortality in the country.

In Davao province, the Tagum city government has been implementing its own reproductive health program, spending at least P1.5 million annually, according to a previous Inquirer report. Since 2006, at least 4,390 women have reportedly availed themselves of the city’s free tubal ligation program.

Stalemate

House members are in a stalemate on HB 4244 after they an adjourned the plenary session on Wednesday without settling Rep. Roilo Golez’s motion to suspend further deliberations on the measure.

Golez wanted the chamber to focus on the devastation caused by the heavy monsoon rains in Metro Manila and neighboring provinces last week, a move dismissed as a dilatory tactic by proponents of the RH bill.

“The scheme of the oppositors to take undue advantage of House Rules on questions of personal or collective privilege to delay and derail the start of the period of amendments, violates the mandate of the plenary to move forward the RH bill,” Lagman said in a statement.

“Why terminate the long-winding and repetitive interpellations only to temporize and hold hostage the legislation?” he added.

No middle ground

But Golez accused the RH bill proponents of delaying the bill themselves when they moved for adjournment on the two session days when the House opened the period of amendments on HB 4244. The decision, according to Golez’s camp, meant that the other side did not have enough numbers on the floor.

Rep. Florencio Noel, who is openly against the bill, said he was not optimistic that both sides could reach a “middle ground” on the measure.

“While there are compromises that can be made, I see that there are more disagreements,” he told the Inquirer on the sidelines of the plenary deliberations. With a report from Norman Bordadora

1 comment:

  1. This is another issue about Tito Sotto in which he called as a lying thief by the american woman who said that he copied his idea about rh bill.

    ReplyDelete

..Into it? Please leave a comment!

Labels

Dolphy (35) Philippines (32) Manny Pacquiao (28) Manny (25) Boxing (24) Pacquiao (24) Pnoy (23) Video (23) Robredo (19) DILG (18) Jesse Robredo (16) Aquino (15) Masbate (15) Tim (14) Cebu (13) Jessica Sanchez (13) Pres. Aquino (13) ABS-CBN (12) Bradley (12) Pinoy (12) X Factor Philippines (12) American Idol (11) Plane crash (11) Tim Bradley (11) Mon Tulfo (10) PBA (10) X Factor (10) Filipino (9) Manila (9) Timothy Bradley (9) Basketball (8) Bob Arum (8) Eat Bulaga (8) Erwin Tulfo (7) Leni Robredo (7) Raffy Tulfo (7) TV5 (7) Ben Tulfo (6) Gloria Arroyo (6) Jesse (6) KC Concepcion (6) Music Video (6) Quizon (6) Timothy (6) Ateneo (5) Carabuena (5) Charice Pempengco (5) Chris Tiu (5) Concert (5) Eulogy (5) Gangnam Style (5) KZ Tandingan (5) Lourd de Veyra (5) NBA (5) Naga City (5) OPM (5) Phillip Phillips (5) Smart Gilas (5) Supreme Court (5) Tito Sotto (5) Vic Sotto (5) Zsa Zsa Padilla (5) 2012 (4) Annabelle Rama (4) Apple (4) Capt. Bahinting (4) Champion (4) China (4) Chiz Escudero (4) Death (4) Derek Ramsay (4) Documentary (4) Dolphy Quizon (4) Earthquake (4) GMA (4) Japan (4) Joey de Leon (4) Juan Manuel (4) Kris Aquino (4) Lourd (4) Manny Pangilinan (4) Manuel Marquez (4) Mar Roxas (4) Marquez (4) Mayweather (4) Mobile phone (4) Ninoy (4) Ninoy Aquino (4) PBA Draft (4) President (4) Raymart Santiago (4) Replay (4) Robert Carabuena (4) Rondo (4) Sec. Jesse Robredo (4) Toshiaki Nishioka (4) Tulfo (4) UK (4) US (4) Zsa Zsa (4) 33rd Anniversary (3) Anabelle Rama (3) Angelica Panganiban (3) Anne Curtis (3) Asia (3) Ate Gay (3) Blue Eagles (3) Boy 2 (3) Celtics (3) Charice (3) Charlie Watts (3) Chito Alcid (3) Chiz (3) Comedy Bar (3) Congressman (3) Corona (3) Eric Quizon (3) Eugene Domingo (3) FIBA (3) FIBA Asia 2012 (3) Floyd (3) Floyd Mayweather (3) Heart Evangelista (3) Jacintha (3) Jinkee (3) Jones Cup 2012 (3) Jose and Wally (3) Kate (3) Kris (3) Mac (3) Marcos (3) Maria Lourdes Sereno (3) Mexico (3) Miami Heat (3) Mindanao (3) News (3) Noli de Castro (3) Nonito Donaire (3) Noynoy Aquino (3) Nurse (3) Olympics 2012 (3) Pacman (3) Patricia Robredo (3) Philippines Tragedy (3) Piolo Pascual (3) Prank call (3) Prsident Aquino (3) RH Bill (3) Raymart (3) Roxas (3) SMART- Gilas (3) Senator (3) Sept. 1 (3) Sereno (3) Sotto (3) USA (3) UST (3) WBO (3) WBO Title (3) Wil Time Big Time (3) Willie Revillame (3) Word of the Lourd (3) iPhone 5 (3) suicide (3) 6th round (2) Actress (2) Allan K. (2) Anti-China (2) Araneta Coliseum (2) Australia (2) Australian DJ (2) Bamboo (2) Barriga (2) Beatles (2) Bench (2) Benigno (2) Blair (2) Blast (2) Boston Celtics (2) Boy 2 Quizon (2) Break up (2) Celebrity (2) Chief Jusice (2) Chief Justice (2) Chinese Taipei (2) Chris (2) Claudine (2) Claudine Barreto (2) Coach (2) Comedy (2) Corruption (2) Cory Aquino (2) Court of Appeals (2) Dave Grohl (2) Derek (2) Donaire (2) Eat Bulaga Indonesia (2) Entertainment (2) FIBA 2012 (2) Filipino boxer (2) Freddie Roach (2) Funny (2) GMA 7 (2) GMA News (2) GMA-7 (2) GMA7 (2) Gary V. (2) Gerald Anderson (2) Ginebra (2) Gloria Macapagal- Arroyo (2) Growling Tigers (2) Heart (2) Heat (2) Hollywood (2) IBF (2) India (2) Indonesia (2) Interview (2) John Lloyd Cruz (2) Jonas Brothers (2) Jones Cup (2) Jones Cup 2012 Championship (2) Jose (2) Joshua Ledet (2) Judy Ann Santos (2) Junemar Fajardo (2) Kate Middleton (2) Kevin Garnett (2) Knock out (2) Korea (2) Korean Rapper (2) LA Tenorio (2) Lady Gaga (2) Legacy (2) Little Miss Philippines 2012 (2) Live (2) London Olympics (2) MILF (2) MMDA (2) MMDA Enforcer (2) MMDA Traffic Enforcer (2) MVP (2) Malacanang (2) Miami (2) Movie (2) Naga (2) Nevada (2) Nonito Donaire Jr. (2) Norman Black (2) Noynoy (2) OFW (2) Oklahoma (2) Oprah (2) Osang (2) PSY (2) Pacquiao- Marquez 4 (2) Paul Pierce (2) Philippine Politics (2) Pidol (2) Pinoy Celebrity (2) Post Fight (2) Prince William (2) Rajon Rondo (2) Rematch (2) Renato Corona (2) Ringo Starr (2) Rufa Mae (2) Rufa Mae Quinto (2) Ruffa Guttierez (2) Ryzza Dizon (2) Samar (2) San Juan (2) Sarah Geronimo (2) Sec. Robredo (2) Sen. Sotto (2) Sen. Tito Sotto (2) Senate (2) Sharon Cuneta (2) Split (2) Split decision (2) Stand up comedian (2) Steve Tyler (2) TV Patrol (2) Tenorio (2) Thinner (2) Thunder (2) Tiu (2) UAAP (2) Vandolph (2) Video Display (2) Wally (2) Wasak (2) X Factor Grand Finals (2) $1M (1) 13 (1) 2013 Elections (1) 24 Oras (1) 30 (1) 35th Gawad Urian (1) 36 (1) 3rd death anniversary (1) 5 Peat (1) 5 in a row (1) 57 (1) 7.6 Magnitude (1) 7.7 Magnitude (1) ADMU (1) AKTV 13 (1) ANC (1) ARM (1) Abrazado (1) Abueva (1) Activist (1) Adam Levine (1) Adventist (1) Aftershocks (1) Aga Mulach (1) Aika (1) Aika Robredo (1) Ako Bicol (1) All at once (1) Allen (1) America (1) Amy (1) Amy Perez (1) Anabelle (1) Anabelle Rama. Rama (1) Android (1) Android Phones (1) Angel Aquino (1) Angelica (1) Angus (1) Angus T. Jones (1) Anne (1) Annebisyosa (1) Apo hiking society (1) Apple shops (1) Archdiocese (1) Archer (1) Arnel Pineda (1) Arroyo (1) Arum (1) Asian (1) Assasination (1) Associate Justice (1) Audio (1) Australian (1) Aviatour (1) Award (1) B-Meg (1) BIR (1) Baguio (1) Bahinting (1) Balita (1) Barangay Ginebra (1) Barrack Obama (1) Barreto (1) Beastie Boys (1) Beautiful stars (1) Beijing (1) Ben (1) Benguet (1) Benigno Aquino III (1) Best Actor (1) Best Actress (1) Bianca Manalo (1) Big Dome (1) Big J (1) Billboards (1) Billiard (1) Birhday (1) Black (1) Blogger (1) Bloggers (1) Bmeg (1) Board Exam (1) Bob (1) Bomb (1) Bong Revilla (1) Boston (1) Brian Viloria (1) Britain (1) Brod Pete (1) Bunawan (1) Burial rites (1) CEO (1) CPDRC (1) Cagayan de Oro (1) Callalily (1) Canada (1) Captain America (1) Caridad Tulfo (1) Carmina Villaroel (1) Cebu City (1) Cebu divers (1) Celebrities (1) Celine Dion (1) Chad Kinis (1) Chairman (1) Championship belt (1) Charlene Gonzalez (1) Christian Bautista (1) Ciara Sotto (1) Cinemalaya (1) Claudin Barreto (1) Co-pilot (1) Coco Martin (1) College (1) Comedy King (1) Comelec (1) Comment (1) Concert Tour (1) Congresswoman (1) Consolacion (1) Conspiracy theory (1) Controversial (1) Cory (1) Country (1) Crash plane (1) Creed (1) Cris (1) Cris Kesz Valdez (1) Crocodile (1) Cry (1) Cyber (1) Cyber Law (1) Cyber crime (1) Cybercrime (1) Cybercrime law (1) DILG Secretary (1) DOTC (1) Daddy's Home. Allen (1) Dance (1) Davao (1) Davao del Sur (1) David Letterman (1) Dawn Zulueta (1) Debate (1) Democratic Convention (1) Denver Cuello (1) Derek Ramsey (1) Device (1) Digram (1) Dionisia (1) Director (1) Disaster (1) Dish (1) Disqualified (1) Divers (1) Dolphy Jr. (1) Don Henley (1) Dong (1) Dong Abay (1) Draft (1) Drummer (1) Drummers (1) Duet (1) Duterte (1) Dwyane Wade (1) Dwyane Wade. Lebron James (1) EB 33 (1) East Finals (1) Economy (1) Eddie Garcia (1) Eddie Guttierez (1) Efren Reyes (1) Elephant (1) Environment (1) Erap (1) Eraserheads (1) Eric Tai (1) Erik Spoelstra (1) Escudero (1) Espinosa (1) Esquire (1) FIBA Asia (1) FIBA Asia Cup (1) Fabros (1) Facebook (1) Faster (1) Felipe Gozon (1) Fernando Poe Jr. (1) Fight plan (1) Fil- Am (1) Filipino Flash (1) Filipino news (1) Filth (1) Finals (1) Finlas (1) Flag (1) Foo Fighters (1) Forbes (1) Fraternity (1) Full Video (1) Gabriel (1) Gadget (1) Game 1 (1) Game 5 (1) Garcia (1) Gary V. Charice Pempengco (1) Gawad Urian (1) Gerry Ortega (1) Gina Rinehart (1) Girlfriend (1) Gloria (1) God (1) Google (1) Grand Finals (1) Grand Winner (1) Grandsons (1) Greatest Hits Album (1) Gringo (1) Guttierez (1) Harden (1) Harry (1) Harry Reid (1) Hayden Kho (1) Hazing (1) Helen Gamboa (1) Henry Sy (1) Hero (1) Hodge (1) Honasan (1) Hospital (1) Hospital arrest (1) Hotel (1) Huling El Bimbo (1) Huling Sayaw (1) Hulk (1) ICU (1) Ikot ng Mundo (1) Illegal Trade (1) Image (1) Imelda (1) Impeachment (1) Indiana Pacers (1) Indie (1) Inmates (1) Intel (1) Internet (1) Iran (1) Ironman (1) It's Showtime (1) Ivory (1) Iza Calzado (1) J.Lo (1) JB (1) JLo (1) James Morrison (1) Jamir Garcia (1) Jarencio (1) Jennifer Holliday (1) Jennifer Lopez (1) Jennifer Sanchez (1) Jessica Soho (1) Jessup (1) Jim Carrey (1) Jim Paredes (1) Jim Toth (1) Joe Adam (1) Joel Reyes (1) Joel Torre (1) John Pratts (1) Jones (1) Jose Rizal (1) Joseph Estrada (1) Journey (1) Juan for all (1) Judges (1) KZ (1) Kamikazee (1) Keith Richards (1) Kevin Durant (1) Kings (1) Kissing scene (1) Knocked out (1) Knockout (1) Krista Ranillo-Lim (1) Kshitz Chand (1) Kuwaiti police (1) Kyla (1) Kyocera Echo (1) Langit (1) Lars Ulrich (1) Laugh and Sing (1) Lebanon (1) Lebron James (1) Letterman Show (1) Lex Leonum Fraternitas (1) Liam Neeson (1) Libel (1) Liz Alindogan (1) Lolong (1) London (1) Lucio Tan (1) Lucy Liu (1) Lucy Torres (1) Luis (1) Luis Manzano (1) MILF Chief (1) MMA (1) MTRCB (1) Mac. iPhone (1) Madison (1) Maja (1) Maja Salavador (1) Makati Hospital (1) Makati Medical Center (1) Malaysia (1) Man of the poor (1) Manalac (1) Manu Ginobilli (1) Manuel Roxas 2 (1) Mar (1) Marbel (1) Maria Aragon (1) Marielle Rodriguez (1) Marilou Diaz-Abaya (1) Mario Reyes (1) Mark (1) Maroon 5 (1) Martin Nievera (1) Mathebula (1) Mayor (1) Mayweather Sr. (1) Media (1) Men In Black III (1) Michael V. (1) Mick Jagger (1) Miley Cyrus (1) Mining (1) Minsan (1) Mirriam (1) Mirriam Santiago (1) Missing (1) Mitt Romney (1) Mom (1) Mon (1) Mother's Day (1) Motorola (1) Msgr. Cristobal Garcia (1) Mugen (1) My Story (1) NCCA (1) National Artist award (1) Nepal (1) Nepalese (1) New Tigers (1) New Zealand (1) Newspapers (1) Nishioka (1) Northern (1) Northern Philippines (1) Noshioka (1) Novak Djokovic (1) Nurses (1) Nursing (1) Nursing Board Exam (1) Obama (1) October 19 (1) Ogie Alcasid (1) Oklahoma Thunder (1) Omar Nino Romero (1) Online (1) Oppa (1) Oscar (1) PBA Finals (1) PH (1) PLDT (1) PLDTm Smart (1) PM (1) Palace (1) Palawan (1) Par Que (1) Party List (1) Passion (1) Paulo (1) Paulo Avelino (1) Peace (1) Peace prize (1) Petron Blaze (1) Phil Collins (1) Philadelphia Sixers (1) Philip Morris (1) Phivolcs (1) Pido Jarencio (1) Pilipinas (1) Pilita Corrales (1) Pilot (1) Pinay (1) Pinoy Gangnam Style (1) Piper Seneca (1) Plane (1) Pnoy. Aquino. Naga (1) Poem (1) Pofile (1) Point guard (1) Police (1) PolyEast Records (1) Pope (1) Pope francis (1) Popular Shows (1) Post (1) Post Fight Interview (1) Powerful (1) Presidentiable (1) Presidential debate (1) Press Conference (1) Priest (1) Prince (1) Prisoners (1) Profile picture (1) Prone (1) Protesters (1) Puyat (1) Qatar (1) Question and answer (1) Quezon City (1) Rage (1) Rain or Shine (1) Ram Revilla (1) Rama (1) Ramgen Revilla (1) Ramon Revilla (1) Ramsey (1) Rapes (1) Ravena (1) Raxr (1) Red Cross (1) Reese Witherspoon (1) Relationship (1) Reproducive Health (1) Revelation (1) Reyes brothers (1) Richest drummer (1) Richest woman (1) Rivalry (1) Robert Jaworski (1) Rock and Roll (1) Rock band (1) Rody Duterte (1) Rolling Stones (1) Romulo (1) Romulo Macalintal (1) Ronnie Wood (1) Ryzza (1) SM (1) Salva (1) Sam Pinto (1) San Antonio (1) Sandiganbayan (1) Santiago (1) Santo (1) Sarah G. Live (1) Sarah Pope (1) Score card (1) Season 11 (1) Season 75 (1) Secretary Robredo (1) Semi- finals (1) Sen. Honasan (1) Senator Chiz (1) Seventh day Adventist (1) Shalani (1) Sharp Aquos Hybrid (1) Sharper (1) Sheryl Cruz (1) Shocking (1) Showbiz (1) Slapshock (1) Smart Araneta Coliseum (1) Smartphone (1) Snapdragon (1) So Funny (1) Social Networking Site (1) Soledad (1) Solo (1) Solo Concert (1) Sony Ericsson (1) Sony Xperia (1) South (1) South East Asi (1) Southborder (1) Spoelstra (1) Spurs (1) Stabs (1) Stand up comedy (1) Steve Jobs (1) Story (1) Street Kid (1) Striegl (1) Study (1) Suit (1) Super Funny (1) Supermoon (1) Survey (1) Susan Roces (1) Sydney (1) T-Mobile G1 (1) TLC (1) TRO (1) Tacurong (1) Tagalog (1) Taipei (1) Taken 2 (1) Takeoff (1) Talk n Text (1) Tanquincen (1) Tax evasion (1) Taxi driver (1) Tennessee James (1) Tennis (1) Thailand (1) The Avengers (1) The Ellen DeGeneres Show (1) The Filipino Flash (1) The Fray (1) The King (1) Third disaster prone (1) This Guy's In Love With You Mare (1) Thor (1) Ticketmaster (1) Tim Duncan (1) Title (1) Tito (1) Tolentino (1) Tomas Osmeña (1) Toni (1) Toni Gonzaga (1) Tony Parker (1) Top 10 (1) Top 9 (1) Top Ten (1) Top athlete (1) Topnotchers (1) Trade (1) Trainer (1) Tribute (1) Tricia (1) Trillanes (1) Trophy (1) Tsinelas (1) Tulfo brothers (1) Twitter (1) Two and a half men (1) U.S Citizen (1) U2 (1) UP (1) US Senator (1) Uge (1) Unconstitutional (1) Upsilon Phi Sigma (1) Valdez (1) Variety Show (1) Vatican (1) Vhong Navarro (1) Vice (1) Vice Ganda (1) Vilma Santos (1) Vitalii Sediuk (1) WBA (1) WBC (1) WBF (1) WPA (1) Wanted (1) Waterfalls (1) Weekend (1) Weigh-in (1) Whitney (1) Will Smith (1) Willie (1) Willing Willie (1) Women (1) World (1) Yacht designer (1) ZTE (1) Zanjoe Marudo (1) Zia Quizon (1) bata (1) biography (1) e-Martial Law (1) gay (1) magazine (1) no. 7 (1) phone (1) sitcom (1) son's death (1)